By Deborah Braidic, MABC, MSc, GAABS Director and GAABS Editorial Board Member
What if the people on the receiving end of your nudge disagree with it, and you can't tell? In a trial across G7 countries, a default vaccination appointment reduced people's intentions to be vaccinated, yet public support for it looked no different from the alternative.
Only when participants were asked to stop and reflect did their disapproval show up. Dr. Sanchayan Banerjee explained to a GAABS webinar what this means for anyone designing choices for others, and offered us a low-cost way to start testing the principle in our own efforts.
Dr. Sanchayan Banerjee is Associate Professor of Economics and Public Policy and Director of the Behavioural Public Policy Lab at King's College London. He spoke with GAABS board director Melina Moleskis about his book, Nudge+: Think Before You Nudge, co-authored with Professor Peter John.
TL;DR
A pause amplifies a nudge people agree with, but can backfire on those who don't.
Short-term effectiveness can hide the wrong signals.
Reflection belongs at strategic points, not everywhere.
Including a reflective prompt in every nudge is a cheap ethical safeguard.
What is a nudge plus?
A nudge, in plain terms, is a change to how a choice is presented that steers people without much conscious thought, such as a default option. A nudge plus adds a prompt to reflect on it.
Many organisations already reflect before and after an intervention. Low-cost prompts can make that explicit: a daily “take a breath and list your main goals” prompt, or cool-off periods that separate a stimulus from an impulsive response.
His example was buyer’s remorse after a rushed car or house purchase, which a pause or a conversation with a trusted person could have prevented.
“So simply put, a nudge plus is a nudge with the prompt to reflect on the nudge”
When a pause helps, and when it backfires
Dr. Banerjee described a UK online study with about 5,500 participants ordering from a pub delivery menu. Some saw a message that vegetarian eating is increasing. In other cohorts, people were first asked about their own views and then shown the distance between those views and the norm.
For about 90% of participants, whose views were already close to the norm, reflecting on that distance produced around twice the uptake of the standard norm message. The remaining 10%, who were far from the norm, moved the other way and increased their consumption of non-vegetarian items.
He likened the effect to a rubber band. A pause aligned with the nudge pulls people further the way you intend. A pause on a nudge people reject can pull them back.
“If you reflect on a nudge that you align with, then you can actually, through that reflection, increase the effectiveness of the nudge. And then, if you do not agree with it, it can backfire.”
The vaccination warning
In trials across G7 countries involving close to 50,000 people in two waves, the team tested a default vaccination appointment. The clinic texts you a time rather than expecting you to self-schedule.
He explained that the default reduced vaccination intentions in every country, and the version with a reflection prompt roughly doubled that drop. Yet public support looked indifferent between the default and self-scheduling. Only when people had reflected did support fall to match their intentions.
“Short-term effectiveness shouldn’t be seen as a guide to choosing interventions, because that could be hiding … signals.”
What this means for you
Measure more than uptake.
Whether it be responses of support or objections, both can be the early warning sign that your intervention might show early success but then ultimately fail.Look at who is in disagreement with your message.
A mathematical average can hide a group that is actively pulling in a different direction. In other words, you may not have the agreement that the metrics might suggest.Build in review moments.
For a 6% pension default, this may suit an individual in specific years, but perhaps not in a year that a child is born or an emergency hits. A prompt at that moment lets people reset their “default” is important.Use cool-offs.
Dr. Banerjee suggested pauses that break the link between a stimulus and an impulsive reaction, since impulsive reactions are often where organisations go wrong.Keep it rare.
Reflection is not something we ask you to do at every point in your life. But rather, they should be limited to strategic points.
“...each intervention from an ethical point of view should come with a momentary pause to get people to think before they get on with the nudge.”
The obvious objection: "This is harder to sell"
Melina Moleskis put it directly: short-term measures like uptake make a Nudge+ hard to sell. Dr Banerjee agreed it can be, but argued that difficulty should not make us less receptive. The choice between a nudge and a nudge+, he said, should not rest on effectiveness alone. Public support and legitimacy matter too.
The limits are worth stating. In the vaccination trials the pause made the headline number worse, not better. He also said reflection could widen gaps between groups or disadvantage groups that are time-poor. His team has not yet tested this for nudge plus, and he called it a working hypothesis.
With regards to artificial intelligence, he indicated that the work on Nudge+ has not yet expanded into that space. With that in mind, he clarified that the case is not "a pause always wins". It is "find out before you scale".
Audience questions
How do you decide when to prompt reflection?
Dr. Bannerjee argued that every intervention should include a momentary pause at first delivery as an ethical safeguard. The book also argues against a strict fast-or-slow dichotomy: people can switch between fast and slow thinking, and reflection is a skill they can call on when needed.
Is the goal for people to eventually nudge themselves?
Broadly yes. Nudge+ sits in the “agency” family alongside boosting, aiming to empower people to take charge. The book also warns of an illusion of self-control (Chapter 7): a bad actor could design the reflection task itself to make people feel in charge while still steering them.
What legacy would you like Nudge+ to have?
That behavioural science stops being equated with nudging alone. Nudges, boosts, Nudge+ and other approaches work through different mechanisms (reflexes, competence, deliberation), and practitioners benefit from a richer toolkit.
Which book would you pair it with?
Boosting by Ralph Hertwig and Till Grüne-Yanoff (due next year), or Superhumans by David Halpern and Elizabeth Costa, both in the same agency camp.
Monday Morning Take-away
Pick one nudge you run or plan to run, such as a default, a reminder or a norm message. Respond to the two prompts below:
A one-line prompt that asks people to pause at the first point they meet it.
Who in your audience sits furthest from your message, and what they might do if it jars.
Bring both to your next 1:1 as the case for a small test. Writing them needs no budget and no sign-off.
Read more
• Book: Nudge+: Think Before You Nudge
• Paper: Nudge+: incorporating reflection into behavioral public policy
About the speaker. Dr Sanchayan Banerjee is Associate Professor of Economics and Public Policy and inaugural Director of the Behavioural Public Policy Lab at King’s College London, a visiting fellow at LSE, and an advisor to PwC Strategy & (Middle East). His research covers food, energy, health and charitable giving.
Edited and condensed from the webinar recording, which will be available on the GAABS website. Figures and quotations are paraphrased from the discussion; please check the book and papers for exact details. The views expressed are those of the speaker.